Is Milk More Hydrating Than Water? What the Studies Actually Show
Is milk more hydrating than water? In short lab tests, yes. Milk keeps more fluid in your body for a few hours. But the reason is simple, the catch is real, and water still does the everyday job very well.
By 1TheWater Editorial Team · BioNatural Co., Ltd. (Ionfarms), a Korean manufacturer of water ionizers and hydrogen water devices since 1998 · Updated October 21, 2026. Disclosure: we make drinking-water products, so we cite only peer-reviewed studies and official sources below.
On October 20, 2026, Daily Galaxy ran a feature claiming milk keeps you hydrated longer than plain water. It built on a Harvard Health review by Dr. Robert Shmerling and the 2016 Beverage Hydration Index trial. A TODAY dietitian segment made the same point earlier this year. So Americans are asking one question: should I swap my water for milk?
- In a 72-person randomized trial, skim and whole milk kept about 1.5 times more fluid at 2 hours than still water.
- The edge comes from electrolytes (sodium, potassium), lactose, protein and fat, not from anything magic in milk.
- Coffee, tea, sparkling water and a sports drink hydrated about the same as still water.
- Milk adds calories. Harvard Health calls the evidence weak and keeps water as the routine choice.
- Water with a meal or a salty snack gives you a similar fluid-plus-minerals combination.
What does "more hydrating" actually mean?
In these studies, "hydrating" has a narrow meaning. Researchers give people a fixed amount of a drink. Then they collect urine for several hours.
Less urine means more of the drink stayed in the body. That is called fluid retention, the share of a drink your body holds on to instead of passing.
This is a fair way to measure short-term hydration. But it is only one way. It does not measure calories, cost, or how a drink fits a daily routine. Keep that in mind as we look at the numbers.
What did the milk vs. water studies find?
Three small trials drive most of the headlines. A fourth helps explain them.
Who: 72 healthy, fasted men at three UK universities. Each drank 1 liter of still water or a test drink over 30 minutes.
What they found: Over 4 hours, urine output was 1,337 g after still water. It was 1,052 g after whole milk, 1,049 g after skim milk, and 1,038 g after an oral rehydration solution.
Why it matters: The team created the Beverage Hydration Index (BHI). It scores how much fluid a drink keeps versus still water. Milk scored about 1.5 at 2 hours. Maughan et al., Am J Clin Nutr
Eleven people sweated off 1.8% of their body mass in a warm room. They then drank 150% of that loss as low-fat milk, water or a sports drink.
Over 5 hours, they passed about 611 mL of urine after milk versus 1,184 mL after water. The milk group stayed in positive fluid balance. The authors noted milk suits everyone except people with lactose intolerance. Shirreffs et al., Br J Nutr
Seven active men lost 2% of body mass through heat and exercise. Five hours after rehydrating, the milk group was about 117 mL ahead of baseline. The water group was about 539 mL behind. Seery & Jakeman, Br J Nutr
Milk permeate is milk with the protein and fat removed. It keeps the sugar and minerals. In 12 young adults, it still beat water and a sports drink on fluid retention over 4 hours.
That points to milk's minerals and sugar as the main drivers. Berry et al., Nutrients
So yes, the data are consistent. Milk holds fluid longer in the first few hours. But these were small groups, mostly young men, measured for half a day at most.
Why does milk stay in your body longer?
Plain water leaves the stomach fast. It reaches the blood quickly and dilutes it slightly. Your kidneys respond by making more urine. That is healthy and normal.
Milk behaves differently for two reasons.
- Electrolytes. These are minerals that carry an electric charge, like sodium and potassium. They help your body hold water in the blood and tissues.
- Nutrients that slow emptying. Lactose (milk sugar), protein and fat make the stomach release fluid more slowly. A slower trickle means a smaller urine response.
Notice what this means. Milk's advantage is not unique to milk. It comes from pairing fluid with minerals and food energy. An oral rehydration solution, which is basically water with salt and sugar, scored just as high.
How do common drinks compare?
Here is how popular drinks performed in the Beverage Hydration Index trial, with practical notes added. The short version: only milk and the oral rehydration solution beat still water.
| Drink | 4-hour retention vs. still water | Calories | Best use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Still water | Baseline | None | All-day hydration |
| Skim milk | Higher | Moderate | Recovery after long, sweaty exercise |
| Whole milk | Higher | Higher | Recovery, if calories fit your plan |
| Oral rehydration solution | Higher | Low to moderate | Illness with fluid loss, heavy sweating |
| Sports drink | No difference | Moderate | Long endurance sessions |
| Coffee or tea | No difference | None to low (plain) | Counts toward daily fluids |
| Sparkling water | No difference | None | A fizzy swap for plain water |
Two takeaways stand out. Coffee and tea hydrate about as well as water, so they are not "dehydrating." And sports drinks did not beat water in rested people.
Should you swap water for milk?
For most people, no. Dr. Robert Shmerling of Harvard Health reviewed the same studies. He called the evidence weak and said he would stick with water for routine hydration.
His reasons are practical.
- Calories add up. Tap water has none. In the seven-man study, the milk serving topped 1,000 calories.
- The gap is modest. In the 72-person trial, it worked out to about 37 ounces of urine after milk versus 47 after water.
- Lactose. Some people do not digest milk sugar well. The 2007 authors flagged this directly.
- Most days are not lab days. You drink across the whole day, usually with meals.
So, is milk more hydrating than water? Per glass, in a fasted lab test, it is. Across a normal day, water plus regular meals covers most healthy adults. Milk earns its place as a recovery drink after long, hot workouts.
What about mineral-rich water?
Water itself can carry small amounts of calcium and magnesium, depending on its source. These minerals are part of what makes tap water taste the way it does. Reverse osmosis strips most of them out. Our Alpha 1700 water ionizer works differently. It filters the water first and keeps the dissolved minerals from your tap. Learn more in how a water ionizer purifies water and our guide to magnesium in drinking water.
To be clear, the BHI trial did not test ionized or alkaline water. We are not claiming it beats milk. The point is simpler. Clean, good-tasting water makes it easier to drink enough every day.
How can you get milk's edge with water?
You do not need milk to keep fluid on board. You need fluid, some electrolytes, and a steady pace. Here is a simple routine.
- Drink water with each meal. Food supplies sodium and potassium, much like milk does.
- Sip through the day instead of chugging a liter at once. Fast, large volumes raise urine output.
- Know your target. The National Academies set adequate total water at about 2.7 L for women and 3.7 L for men.
- After a long, hot workout, add a salty snack, or have a glass of milk if it suits you.
- Count coffee, tea and sparkling water. They hydrate about as well as still water.
- Keep water easy to reach. A bottle you like, such as the portable H2CAP Plus hydrogen water bottle, helps the habit stick.
- If you have kidney, heart or other medical conditions, ask your physician for a personal fluid plan.
Curious whether other water types change the picture? See does hydrogen water hydrate better and our broader guide, what kind of water should we drink. For more articles like this one, visit our Wellness & Nutrition hub.
Frequently asked questions
Is milk more hydrating than water?
In short lab tests, yes. In a 72-person randomized trial, skim and whole milk kept about 50% more fluid at 2 hours than still water. The effect comes from milk's sodium, potassium, sugar, protein and fat. For everyday hydration, water still works well and adds no calories.
Why does milk hydrate better than water?
Milk contains electrolytes, mainly sodium and potassium, plus lactose, protein and fat. These slow how fast fluid leaves the stomach and help the kidneys hold on to water. Plain water empties quickly, so the body passes more of it as urine in the first few hours.
Is skim milk or whole milk more hydrating?
In the Beverage Hydration Index trial, the two were almost identical. Over 4 hours, urine output was about 1,049 g after skim milk and 1,052 g after whole milk. Still water produced 1,337 g. Skim milk gives the same effect with fewer calories.
Should I drink milk instead of water every day?
No. Harvard Health's Dr. Robert Shmerling calls the evidence for milk weak and keeps water as the routine choice. Milk adds calories, and some people do not tolerate lactose. Milk makes the most sense as a recovery drink after long, sweaty exercise.
What is the most hydrating drink?
In the 2016 Beverage Hydration Index study, an oral rehydration solution, skim milk and whole milk scored highest. Coffee, tea, sparkling water, cola, diet cola, orange juice, lager and a sports drink matched still water over 4 hours.
Does water with food hydrate as well as milk?
It can come close. Milk works because it pairs fluid with electrolytes and nutrients. Drinking water with a meal or a salty snack supplies similar ingredients. The National Academies estimate that about 20% of daily water already comes from food.
How much water should I drink a day?
The National Academies set adequate total water at about 2.7 liters a day for women and 3.7 liters for men. That includes all drinks and food. Heat, exercise and illness raise needs. If you have a kidney or heart condition, ask your physician for a personal target.
Where can you go next?
Alpha 1700 Water Ionizer
Filtered, mineral-friendly water from your own tap, made in Korea with an Optimized 7 SMART Plate cell.
See the Alpha 1700Wellness & Nutrition
Plain-English guides on hydration, minerals and everyday habits, backed by published research.
Browse the hubWholesale & Distribution
Retailer or distributor? Ask about wholesale pricing for our ionizers and hydrogen water bottles.
Request wholesale pricingThis article is for general education only. It is not medical advice and does not diagnose, treat or prevent any condition. The studies cited were small and short, and most involved healthy young adults. Have a medical condition, a pregnancy, or medication that affects fluid balance? Talk with your physician before changing what or how much you drink.
- Maughan RJ, Watson P, Cordery PA, et al. A randomized trial to assess the potential of different beverages to affect hydration status: development of a beverage hydration index. Am J Clin Nutr. 2016;103(3):717-723. doi:10.3945/ajcn.115.114769
- Shirreffs SM, Watson P, Maughan RJ. Milk as an effective post-exercise rehydration drink. Br J Nutr. 2007;98(1):173-180. doi:10.1017/S0007114507695543
- Seery S, Jakeman P. A metered intake of milk following exercise and thermal dehydration restores whole-body net fluid balance better than a carbohydrate-electrolyte solution or water in healthy young men. Br J Nutr. 2016;116(6):1013-1021. doi:10.1017/S0007114516002907
- Berry CW, Wolf ST, Murray B, Kenney WL. Hydration efficacy of a milk permeate-based oral hydration solution. Nutrients. 2020;12(5):1502. doi:10.3390/nu12051502
- Shmerling RH. When replenishing fluids, does milk beat water? Harvard Health Publishing. November 14, 2022. health.harvard.edu
- National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. Report sets dietary intake levels for water, salt, and potassium. 2004. nationalacademies.org
- Amiri A. Better than water? Scientists find this everyday drink keeps you hydrated longer. Daily Galaxy. October 20, 2026. dailygalaxy.com